Part I: Summary of Recent Events and Parties Impacting
the Media in Sierra Leone
National Provisional Ruling Council (NPRC)
On April 29, 1992, approximately 17 junior military officers seized power in a
bloodless coup d'etat and were quickly joined by officers of the paramilitary
State Security Department (SSD) who collectively engaged in mass looting
throughout Freetown, especially of goods awaiting customs clearance at the Queen
Elizabeth II quay. General Momoh fled to Guinea and 24-year-old Captain
Valentine E. Strasser was declared Chairman of the National Provisional Ruling
Council (NPRC). Many citizens initially welcomed the change from the 23-year
dictatorial APC regime, that was perceived as old and corrupt. This explains
why thousands of citizens rushed into Freetown's streets to welcome a military
coup that had overthrown an elected government. However, political and economic
deja-vue quickly set in.
The NPRC enlisted support from a pool of private groups and individuals with the
skills necessary to retain military control of the government. Ukrainian pilots
were hired to pilot the two military helicopters based in Freetown. They also
performed topographical surveys together with the South African mercenary group,
Executive Outcomes. There was no shortage of willing and able partners ready to
earn crisis pay, sometimes in diamonds.
The NPRC junta immediately suspended the 1991 Constitution, declared a state of
emergency, and enacted a rule-by-decree policy. The army and all national
security forces, including the SSD and senior police officers were granted
unlimited powers of administrative detention without charge or trial, and
challenges against such detentions in court were precluded. The NPRC misread
citizen's initial embrace as acceptance of poor governance and corruption and
when the press continued to publish critical reports with headlines like, "How
Sincere are the NPRC?" "Villains or Redeemers?" and "When Will Property
Confiscation Stop?" the regime retaliated against the scrutiny.
Some journalists publicly questioned the NPRC "boys" (junior officers) promises
to facilitate a return to democracy. The media's apprehension was realized
when, in a May 5, 1992, national television and radio broadcast, Chairman
Strasser canceled the elections the APC had scheduled for later that year, and
informed the nation that the NPRC would end the war and return the country to
constitutional rule "within three years." The media reacted by doggedly
challenging the NPRC on its policies, or lack thereof, warning fellow citizens
about the probability of the regime perpetuating its rule as other military
regimes had done in Ghana, Burkina Faso, Guinea, and Nigeria. Thus, the battle
lines between the media and NPRC were formally drawn.
On July 10, 1992, the NPRC struck at the press with Decree 6, The Press
Guidelines, of which Section 15 authorized the Post Office General Manager to
confiscate any materials "from or to any territory" and submit them to a State
Censor for as long as "he deems necessary." Section 16 of the decree stated
that publications or broadcasts that influence "public opinion" in a manner
likely to be prejudicial to public safety, public tranquillity, maintenance of
public order" can be restricted. And Section 17 stated, "Any person who
publishes any report or statement which is likely to cause alarm or despondency
or be prejudiced to public safety, public tranquillity or maintenance of public
order "may face a fine of up to (US $1,000) or up to five years imprisonment."
The media reacted passively to Decree 6, in fear of prosecution and detention.
However, a newspaper named Lauda Merci (pidgin English for "Lord Have Mercy")
soon surfaced in the Gambia, and made its way to Freetown via 4-times weekly
Ghana Airways flights from Banjul. NPRC officials received their copies of
Lauda Merci via the postal service. A number of local journalists anonymously
submitted articles to Lauda Merci for publication. The NPRC accused Dr. Abdulai
Conteh, former APC Vice-President and Attorney General who was in exile in the
Gambia after the coup, of being the editor of Lauda Merci, a charge he denied.
But later, fearing for his life because of the collegial relationship between
Gambian military dictator Captain Yahya Jammeh and Chairman Strasser, Conteh
subsequently fled to England.
In late 1992, a new Civil Defense Force (CDF) was created in Kenema under the
leadership of Dr. Alpha Lavarlie to defend rural areas from RUF attack. The CDF
was commonly referred to as the Kamajors (a Mende term for "local hunters")
because it recruited local farmers who were familiar with the countryside and
could more successfully maintain its security. In February 1998, under the
leadership of Deputy Defense Minister Chief Sam Hinga Norman, the Kamajors would
fight side-by-side with ECOMOG soldiers to reinstate President Kabbah. On
February 1, 1993, upon the order of the NPRC Information Secretary, the Press
Re-Registration Guidelines were issued for all newspapers to comply with by
February 8. The guidelines demanded full access to newspapers' printing
plates/dummy sheets 24 hours in advance of press time. This action effectively
banned 19 independent newspapers, while other succumbed to self-censorship in
order to survive. The NPRC used this as a means to determine which media would
support them under duress because the decision had already been made to retain
power longer than they had originally states. The following requirements of the
Press Guidelines sealed the fate of those 19 newspapers:
-
"a fixed asset to a value of not less than
5 million leones (or <5,600 or
US$8,716) together with a cash deposit of 1 million leones in an interest
bearing account in any local commercial bank..." for newspapers;
-
(vi) the editor must be either a degree holder, or a holder of diploma in
mass communications, or one who has been a journalist for 15 years (with 5 years
in an editorial position); and
-
(vii) a registration fee of 50,000 leones (US $35) after settling other tax
requirements with the Income Tax Department."
These NPRC Press Guidelines forcibly reduced the press from approximately 30
weekly newspapers to 10 publications, two of which were state-controlled.
Information Secretary Hindolo Trye (who reported to Public Liaison Officer
Captain Julius Maada Bio) supervised the re-registration scheme. Hindolo's
prior experience as a journalist benefited a few of his former colleagues. When
then Concord Times editor David Tam-Baryoh was arrested in August 1994, Hindolo
intervened to help secure his release. However, Hindolo's sympathetic actions
ended when NPRC junior officers began suspecting and accusing him of being a
traitor for appealing for journalists' release from detention.
In addition to the use of anti-press decrees and registration requirements, the
NPRC routinely arrested journalists to control news coverage, particularly in
response to reports on government corruption connected to the war effort. On
January 11, 1993, NPRC Vice Chairman Solomon Anthony Musa summoned Chernoh Ojuku
Sesay, editor of The Pool, to the Criminal Investigations Department (CID) after
the newspaper reprinted an article from London-based West Africa magazine
reporting that Musa had traveled to Belgium to buy arms. At CID headquarters,
Musa assaulted Sesay in the presence of CID head Teddy Williams (who later
became Inspector General of Police), rendering him unconscious. Fellow
journalists feared similar treatment, and because of the necessity to publish
and earn their daily bread, were even less inclined to take chances with "the
boys." Sesay was targeted with harassment by NPRC officials and subsequently
wrote a letter of apology Vice Chairman Musa, against the advice of his deputy
editor. When Sesay's letter of apology was published in the state-owned Daily
Mail (edited by Martin Mondeh, the brother of NPRC third-in-command, Captain
Komba Mondeh), Sesay's colleague resigned in protest. After the New Breed
newspapers October 13, 1993 edition published an editorial titled "Redeemers or
Villains?" about corruption and diamond smuggling by NPRC officials, most of its
staff was arrested. The New Breed had demanded that the government respond to
an article published in the Swedish newspaper Expression, reporting that
Chairman Strasser flew to Antwerp to sell US $43 million worth of diamonds. On
August 15, 1995, after a 22-month trial, then New Breed managing editor Dr.
Julius Spencer (now President Kabbah's Minister of Information), acting editor
Donald John, sales manager Alfred Conteh, and printer Alusine Basiru, were
convicted on 10 counts of seditious libel. The journalists were sentenced to
stiff fines ranging from 400,00-800,000 leones each (US $150-300), or one-year
prison terms in the event they could not pay the fines.
In December 1993, the NPRC reiterated its promise to return the country to a
multi-party political system within three years, despite the fact that the
National Advisory Council (NAC) had recommended a 15-month time frame. The NAC
had been established by Decree No. 7 of November 1992, as amended by Decree No.
3 of April 1994, to draft a new constitution and prepare for the transition to
democracy. It Ahmed Tejan Kabbah, who had returned to Sierra Leone after
leaving his position with the United Nations Development Programme, was put in
charge of the NAC and its role in the multiparty elections scheduled for
December 1995.
The NPRC's pronouncements about democracy were not accompanied by a commitment
to a freedom of the press or expression. On the occasion of the NPRC's first
anniversary in power, Chairman Strasser announced the repeal of repressive press
laws, but they were simply replaced by new Press Guidelines issued on February
1, 1994, that enacted similar steep fees and strict registration requirements.
As the Liberian-backed RUF insurgency gained momentum and the national army grew
increasingly mutinous, NPRC Information Secretary Hindolo Trye announced, on
November 24, 1994, that all information about military operations would be
subject to censorship for a four-week period. According to the government
order, the news blackout was intended to ensure the secrecy of state maneuvers
against the RUF. Yet news about the war was the "only news worth reporting" in
the eyes of independent journalists. The order generally went unheeded, despite
the arrests of several journalists. And journalists who did make what was
perceived as a futile attempt to clear discouraging news on the war with the
high command at Cockrill were also targeted for arrest. During this time,
rumors of misappropriation of funds were rampant, with private businessmen
donating heavily to the war effort, to curry favor with the regime and gain
valuable contracts. At the time, the NPRC claimed it was spending 8 million
leones (US $3,000) daily on the war.
Simultaneously, the identity of the perpetrators of attacks against civilians
became increasingly difficult for human rights groups to establish. In addition
to the RUF, atrocities were also carried out by subversive factions within the
army who were opposed to the NPRC, and the government was forced to admit that
grave problems of indiscipline existed. During this time, some senior army
officers were accused of collaborating and conniving with the RUF to overthrow
the NPRC. An example of this is the arrest on treason charges of Lieutenant
Colonel Chernor Malado Deen, who was sentenced to death and later pardoned by
President Kabbah. The media was subsequently restricted from identifying
"sobels" (soldier rebels) who were looting and terrorizing citizens in the rural
areas. By restricting reporting on human rights abuses committed by government
soldiers to protect its image as a unified force against the RUF, the NPRC may
have damaged its impact on the RUF by allowing sobels to perpetuate their crimes
without national scrutiny.
The NPRC's retaliation against critical journalists was usually swift. On April
13, 1995, military police arrested Vision editor Siaka Massaquoi and reporter
Max Corneh without charge and detained them for five days in response to an
editorial criticizing the NPRC for the military's cowardly response to a rebel
attack at Waterloo (approximately 10 miles southeast of Freetown). Massaquoi's
commentary, that the NPRC had organized a concert while rebels were in their
backyard, exemplified the citizenry's lack of confidence in the military "boys"
abilities to control the war. That the attack on Waterloo occurred the same day
that Jamaican-born Reggae musician Joseph Hills was performing at an
NPRC-sponsored concert at the National Stadium simply added insult to injury in
the eyes of the media. The government claimed the article was a "morale booster"
for the rebels, despite the fact that residents of Freetown, rather than rebels
in the bush, had access to newspapers that were not being distributed nationally
at the time. Simultaneously, politicians who were afraid of the NPRC began
using the press to pressure them into holding elections. The "paid press"
jumped at the opportunity to earn extra income, resulting in the emergence of
two factions: the anti-elections media, led by the Vision's Siaka Massaquoi and
Hilton Fyle, and the pro-elections media, led by Concord Times' Lansana Gberie
and David Tam-Baryoh. During the April 27, 1995, 34th Independence Address to
the nation, Chairman Strasser announced that the ban on political activity,
enforced since1992, would be lifted in preparation for legislative and
presidential elections scheduled for June 1995, and proposed an immediate
cease-fire and negotiations with the RUF. The RUF rejected these overtures, and
responded by calling for a withdrawal of foreign ECOMOG troops and Executive
Outcomes mercenaries, and for the NPRC to cede power to an interim government.
The RUF did not apply for registration as a political party, although 15 other
political parties did register to contest the elections.
Despite the lifting of the ban on political parties in June, and the preparation
for elections, the NPRC continued to detain journalists for publishing
"annoying" articles. The result was the continued scant coverage of the war
being waged by all parties involved against innocent civilians. Reports citing
poor performance, defections by government troops, or the involvement of Liberia
in the war, were treated as extremely sensitive and rigorously censored.
Additional examples of this censorship include the following:
-
The March 13, 1995, arrest of Week End Spark reporter Rowland Martyn, by
CID agents, for publishing a photograph of an unnamed army officer who had
defected to the RUF. The photo was accompanied by the following text: "The New
African Soldier. Your body reflects what you eat, so too your army is what you
provide for it. A well trained and equipped soldier reflects a wise deterrent
policy for the preservation of peace and freedom... let us all learn from the
bitterness of the past... let our army reflects our true character... what we eat. A
dedication to all our patriotic soldiers dead or alive."
-
In May 1995, when
500 SLA soldiers reportedly defected to the RUF from the Teko Barracks in
Makeni, the media was banned from reporting the incident.
-
On July 12, 1995, when Standard Times editor Ibrahim Karim-Sei quoted a
delegate of the peace conference, held in Yamassoukro, Cote d'Ivoire, who
described the South African mercenary group Executive Outcomes as "hard-core
attack dogs of apartheid," he was imprisoned without charge for 10 days.
-
And in mid-August 1995, then Concord Times editor David Tam-Baryoh's report
that the NPRC had provided arms to ULIMO-K fighters in Liberia, resulted in his
arrest. Tam-Baryoh's article was accompanied by an editorial titled, "Breaking
International Protocol? Taylor Shall Hit Us!" commenting that the NPRC's action
was a violation of ECOWAS protocol prohibiting the interference of any nation
into the internal affairs of another state. Two days later, when Charles
Taylor's NPFL fighters attacked Sierra Leone in retaliation for Sierra Leone's
support of ECOMOG military actions against Taylor, NPRC Secretary of State for
Foreign and International Relations Dr. Abass Bundu ordered Tam-Baryoh's arrest.
Judging from the actions of key NPRC proponents of media repression, such as
Attorney General Claude V.M. Campbell, Captain Idriss Kamara, Minister of
Information Hindolo Trye, Public Liaison Officer Captain Julius Maada Bio,
Captain Solomon Anthony (SAJ) Musa, and Public Relations Officer Rtd. Captain
Abdulrahman Kamara, the NPRC's policy toward the press was reactionary, and far
from a coordinated strategy. Local journalists interpreted the NPRC's attacks
on their profession as proof that, "if the elected APC governments under Stevens
and Momoh did not allow for criticism, the military "boys" (junior officers),
which did not have a mandate from the people to rule, certainly would not
tolerate it either
During the months preceding the elections, which had been postponed from
December 1994 to February 1996, some of the worst atrocities committed against
civilians were at the hands of the RUF. For example, slogans denouncing the
elections were carved into victims' backs and chests, and their hands were
amputated as symbolic messages to civilians not to cast votes. However, there
were also elements within the NPRC who did not want elections to take place, as
evinced by remarks made by Brigadier Joy Turay at the National Consultative
Conference, when he stated, "the Army cannot guarantee security if the people
want elections."
In January 1996, NPRC Chairman Strasser was overthrown by his second-in-command,
Brigadier Julius Maada Bio, but this sudden change did not derail the transition
to civilian rule. A national consultative congress overwhelmingly decided that
elections should proceed despite the country's prevailing state of emergency.
In February 1996, the NPRC commenced discussions with representatives of the
RUF, such as Corporal Foday Sankoh, Dr. Dean Jalloh, and Saia Musa, and the
eagerly anticipated electoral process was officially underway. As one of its
last official acts, the NPRC issued the Indemnity and Transition Decrees, 1996,
which provided immunity from prosecution for acts committed since 1992 by NPRC
officials, the armed forces, and those acting upon the orders of the NPRC. The
inclusion of a similar clause in the Lome Peace Accord was not without
precedent.
Once election campaigning was underway, Kabbah's Campaign Chief, Thorlu Bangura,
promised press freedom in a speech at the National Consultative Conference,
should the Sierra Leone People's Party (SLPP) win office. Kabbah's primary
competition was from Dr. John Karefa-Smart and his United National People's
Party (UNPP), which would later become the most significant opposition party in
the Parliament.
The election was monitored by international and regional groups including the
United Nations, the British Commonwealth, US President Jimmy Carter, and a
delegation from ECOWAS. In the larger cities like Freetown, Bo, Makeni, Kenema,
and Kono, the elections were judged free and fair. However, in smaller towns
such as Blama, Kabala, Sandah, which were under RUF control, there were reports
of citizens who attempted to travel to the larger towns to vote, being amputated
by rebels who attacked them for attempting to vote.
|